I got this mail from anonymous source. This seems to be a reply from one of the faction being accused of corruption. I request you all to comment on the same.
Its really bad to see that having passed out as MACTIAN and being perfectly taught in MACT we fail to see that the things being talked about of our institute are on a false basis.I have gone through Mr. Buch report and I personally find it strange ,the fact being that MANIT is continuously being rated higher and higher. This year 6 new B.Tech courses have been started and everyone is busy in developing these courses along with the director and administration. Now the institute is having courses in B.Tech as well as in M.Tech as per IITs. This is the best thing, which the institute has done and will be very helpful in getting IIT status.
I am well aware of the ongoing court case of Dr. Ashutosh Sharma against Asst. Prof. Savita Raje and Rekha Jain of Architecture Department in the high court regarding seniority and promotion.I met him many times and I found him to be of dynamic personality. I feel that is why he is Dean Administration and HOD as well. It is his efforts and the efforts of the present visionary Director of this institute that MHRD has started thinking of making our intitute an IIT. Friends I personally ask you all as we all are working in Multinational Organisation that a person with higher capabilities can become senior to the person who is just senior and having no capabilities. Thus is it his mistake to accept the post of Dean Administration just because he is junior to Prof Gayatri Agnihotri, Prof Ganga Agnihotri and Prof R.P. Singh etc.Just think on this line.
So a group of Professors are of course jealous and acting negatively against him. Unfortunately as a result of this jealousy they intend to defame MANIT. This is really saddenning. I am reading lot of mails reacting on Mr. Buch report. I ask you who is Mr. Buch? Are we so weak to just believe all what is being shown to us? No we are MACT ians and we will not believe on rumors and false moves. Is it not possible that Mr. Buch became party with Savita Raje and a group of annoyed professors and acted one sided and commented negative on prof. Asutosh Sharma without verifying the truth. We being learned Engineers and Mactian should not believe all this nonsense.
How it is possible that without undergoing all the procedures and formalities laid down by Govt. of India, construction work can be allotted to anybody. Every year there is a audit by Center Audit Deptt. I have gone through the truth and I found that in 2006-07 the firm S.S. Construction has works of Approx. 2 Crores and not of 6.0 Crores. We all know that in every Govt/Semi Govt organizations there are specific 5-7 contractors doing all the works of that organizations. You can see such examples in PWD, PHE Municipal Corporation or Capital Projects or any Development authorities in India. If contractor is being awarded a work through all legal procedures with lowest rate of contract then what is the problem? Work may be done by S.S. Construction or by Firm Chandwani builders or Bansal construction or any other firm, how does it matters when the procedure is as per rules and regulations and all the accounts have been verified by the audit committee. It is really shameful on Mr. Buch part. It itself reflects that he has made one-sided report.
I know 60 faculty members were recruited two year back through a prescribed selection committee constituted by Govt. of India having 2 subject experts from various IITs, NITS and others from AICTE & UGC. How can a person whom so ever he is, singly comments on the procedures of selection committee? Institute had done commendable job by recruiting new faculties. The institute needs 80 more new faculty members to be recruited this year. Students are getting educations through contract faculty instead of regular faculty. If you talk about relatives of faculty members in this institute, then we all must be aware of three sisters-Prof. Ganga Agnihotri, Prof. Geeta Agnihotri and Prof. Gayatri Agnihotri are doing job in this institute.We know that Prof. Siddiqui who is husband of Prof. Gayatri Agnihotri also retired as professor and husband of their fourth sister Prof.R.N. Dubey is also working in Physics department since very long time. Like this many examples can be seen . Prof G. Dixit in Applied Mechanics and his wife in Chemistry Deptt, Asst Prof Tripta thakur in Electrical Deptt. and her husband Mukul kulshrestha in Civil Deptt., Asst. Prof Manmohan Kapshe and Asst. Prof. Charu kapshe both brother and sister are working in Architecture Deptt since 1992, Prof Anil sharma in civil Deptt. and his wife Anupama Sharma in Arch. Deptt. and her father Prof Khurasia got retired from Mechanical Deptt., Prof. Telang and his son, Prof Rawtani Ex-Dean and his son Asst..Prof.Lavit rawtani, Prof Sanjay Soni in applied Mechanics and his father Prof L.L. Soni, Prof Meenu chawla HOD CS Deptt and her father Late Prof. S.C. Jain, Asst.Prof.Namita shrivastava of maths deptt. is daughter of Mr.K.N.Shrivastava Ex-Principal of MACT and many many more. They all are working in this institute since so long and they have taught us all. Now why the question of teachers being relatives is arising since last two years after the recruitment of the regular teachers were made. This is ridiculous. Why cant be a son/daughter in the same profession in which his father is ! Why cant be son, daughter of the teacher can opt her carrier as teacher in the same Institute. All this defamation is I think production of the minds of a group of teachers of the institute who are working negatively and having their own intrestin acting so.
It is very surprising to note that all our senior teachers who are behind this defamation are not at all doing teaching. New recruited faculties are doing all teaching very well along with contract faculties . The load of teaching is being with new faculty. Hey guys may be through this mail they will start teaching instead of playing politics. Mr. Buch so called IAS himself must be having some political agenda behind this which he has implemented.
Madam Savita Raje who is running a NGO with Mr. Buch, which is not only illegal but also against the ethics of teachers. She should spend atleast some time in teaching.You must know one more fact that Mr.Buch submitted his report in june end. You all will be surprised to know that Madam Savita Raje when she was about to loose the Case in high court against Prof Ashutosh Sharma, she filed a caviet asking the favor of Buch report and asked the court that in the Buch report the matter is connected to her,so please do not give stay or something against that report, when no body even Chairman or the Director was aware of the contents of the report officially. It is very clear that she and her NGO made the report.This is a conspiracy of a group of teachers of institute itself who are defaming MANIT in their own intrest and out of mere jealousy. Mr Buch acted like puppet of this group. In the same NGO present editor Shri A Khandelkar of Danik Bhaskar is the member. Now it is obvious why Dainik Bhaskar is publishing such nonsense about MANIT day after day. Please open Architects website to know more of Madam Raje and Madam rekha Jain.
You will be surprised to know how can national newspaper publish one-sided report so openly without taking views of other side. Newspaper editor neither verified the details with the director.
It was really surprised that versions of Dr. Chande were published who was even rejected for the post of lecturer in MACT when he applied long back. No. views of the present director was taken for the article of Dainik Bhaskar who has served 35 years in NIT Trichi and has vast teaching and research experience before being selected in MANIT. Director Sirs wife is Ex Director NIT-Kashmir and presently working as director in Sant Longowala Institute and also being selected as Director NIT-Raipur. How can literate person compare Dr. Chande with Prof Dr. K.S. Pandey? I feel we should not believe on nonsense fake news without verifying the facts and condemn Mr.Buch report and don’t promote support to any type of defaming act.i know that classes are going well and result is excellent and students are getting 100% placement & what I am saying mean I really mean it. We should all join our hands to discourage these NGOs who are defaming the institute. There is one NGO run be LecturerLaxmi Kumre and her husband. When administration found he M.Tech thesis totally copied, the director caught her and Senate rejected her work then her husband Mr. Sharad Kumre started spreading nonsense things about the institute. Even his PIL was rejected by high court for the same. He is defaming our institute for his own interest. Kindly send your views what MANITian should do against these NGOs. Now to run their NGOs they have started asking money from MACTina for their own purpose.
MANIT is healthy and there is need to cure this particular group of annoyed teachers and outsiders so as to SAVE MANIT.
The real culprits are Ganga,Gayatri, Sh.&SmtKumre , Savita raje and Mr. B.R.Nayak(who had been terminated for 8 years from the institute in the case of molestation of a minor girl student).
We must do something against all this if we are all powerful enough in our respective field..We must question how can a national newspaper publish such news base on onesided M.N.Buch report.
Be careful because time is not far when you will receive a mail for the same from ENEMIES OF OUR INSTITUTE.
MANIT is Ranked 4th among all NITs(Times of India),more than 100% placement of students,95% attendance(for the 1st time in history of MACT),Organizing Technical and Cultural events in very large scale,Achieved Golden jublee conduction of NASA, 6 new B.Tech courses,14 new M.Tech program and MBA courses, what more progress do we expect from administration which is working day and night to give IIT status to MANIT.What I plea from my seniors and juniors to do something constructive rather than distructive. Please save the future of our juniors and MANIT
6 comments:
Hi All,
I passed out in 2007 from MANIT and I feel that the truth should come out .....read on ....
***** "This is the best thing, which the institute has done and will be very helpful in getting IIT status."
Merely starting new branches doen not take the college to IIT standards !! Furthermore There is not such plan of upgrading any NIT as IIT , the BJP govt. suggested this and now BJP is nowhere to be seen hence forget bt this.
***** "Friends I personally ask you all as we all are working in Multinational Organisation that a person with higher capabilities can become senior to the person who is just senior and having no capabilities"
MANIT works like a multinational organization !!!!! Cant think of a better Joke !!!
*** "I ask you who is Mr. Buch? Are we so weak to just believe all what is being shown to us? No we are MACT ians and we will not believe on rumors and false moves. Is it not possible that Mr. Buch became party with Savita Raje and a group of annoyed professors and acted one sided and commented negative on prof. Asutosh Sharma without verifying the truth."
Who is Mr. Buch !!! He is a retired IAS officer appointed to verify irregualrities going on in MANIT and as far are verification is concerned I my can assure that every single thing is correct if fact Mr. Buch has missed quite a lot of things, and btw we are not so weak to believe , in fact strong enough to take this up on a bigger level !
***** " If contractor is being awarded a work through all legal procedures with lowest rate of contract then what is the problem? "
For years sanjeev saxena has been taking every contract in manit , his goons would not let any other contractor inside the college. Come on we studied in MACT , this is not at all a secret !!!
***** "The institute needs 80 more new faculty members to be recruited this year. Students are getting educations through contract faculty instead of regular faculty."
These so called faculty members taught me .... A big bunch of idiots who dont deserve to be called "FACULTY" It is too holy a word to be associated with these goons ..... and btw maybe it is one among them who has written " Students are getting educations !!!"
***** Why cant be son, daughter of the teacher can opt her carrier as teacher in the same Institute.
Yes Son/Daughter can ....but when son,daughter,wife,wife's sister, sanjeex saxena;s sister and the whole family joins in it then smthing is fishy , also I know Aruna Saxena , that lady does not deserve to be TPO , just go and talk to her for 5 minutes you will know why.
***** "It was really surprised that versions of Dr. Chande were published who was even rejected for the post of lecturer in MACT when he applied long back."
For everyones information Dr. Chande is a renowned academician was Director of GSITS Indore, Headed Mahindra British Telecoms Software academy at pune , Served as a professor at IIM Indore ..... I dont thing anybody can raise a doubt on his capability and as far as he being rejected for post of lecturer is concerned it is quite obvious .... this is the biggest proof that some of the most competent people are rejected and people who are not worth being a Lab Assistant are made professors .
*******"95% attendance(for the 1st time in history of MACT),"
Come on ... 4 months back I was in MANIT ..... 95% absence is only thing I can think of .... did u forget the legendry GTs of our college ...
... There is a lot to say .... will write some other time .....
I dont think we are getting anywhere by playing this kind of Blame Game.First the faculty writes, then students and alumni and then people from the other side of the table. Raising questions on personal front are not the requirement as the idea is to keep up the spirit and dignity of MACT/ MANIT which is a Institue and not a Political field.
If there are differences among faculties then instead of blogging it ,speak it out and take creative actions. By reading all these comments on the net , it is evident that action and reaction of some of the most learned persons of the institute.
I think this needs to end and if the Government has proposed some actions ,we should all wait patiently for the outcome.
These learned persons after having such Vast experience behind them should work together and refrain from such irresponsible activities which is not expected from Mentors or Guru's whom we all have looked upto.
Work to make MANIT an IIT instead of battle grounds of Kurukshetra.
I totally agree with you....This is not a platform to bring your personal grudes...in fact teachers are expected to set examples for we students....please dont make us loose respect for you all.....there is still time to stop this and do something creative to improve the image of the institute which you all have spoiled for your own wasted interest.....come on teachers thing big and dont become a party to the three sisters and definately not like tripta thakur and her stinking language and dirty morales.....please stop this and let us all be proud of you all ....for a change listen to a student who really cares for you all.
Cmparing Ashutosh Sharma with multinational companies where a junior can become senior because of his capabilities! If Ashutosh Sharma applies in any multinational company, he will not get any job! His only capability is to nurture sanjeev saxena and his family for his benefit. Outside MANIT he is nothing. He even got his admission on Freedom fighter quota, not at all on merit!
Of course the people who have benefitted from this Ashutosh Sahrma+sanjeev saxena nexus will speak in favour of them, BUT IT IS THE TRUTH THAT THE NEXUS IS WORKING TO DESTROY THE QUALITY OF EDUCATION AT MANIT AND WANTS ONLY CHAMCHAAS AND BACKBONELESS AND SCARED PEOPLE TO REMAIN THERE.
It was the MHRD who constituted the enquiry and appointed the respectable Mr. Buch. The fault of Mr. Buch is that he is totally honest and not at all buyable. And the Honorable Minsiter Arjun Sigh ji has already announced action on his report, respecting his report. Now whoever is this person saying a lot of rubbish about respectable persons, is being highly disrespectful to the Honourable Minister Arjun Singh ji and the MHRD.
Please be assured truth will prevail always, come what may.
Few points -
Firstly, this doesn't counter any of the points about irregularities made in earlier posts, but raises new allegations. so this doesn't absolve the greats like Sanjiv Saxena, Ashutosh Sharma, Baghel and his chamchas from charges. (Although the funniest part of the post was the 95% attendence thing!!!)
Secondly, about Prof Chande mentioned in the post -
I have been a student for nearly 2 years both under Dr. Chande's tenure and 2 years before he came. Describing him as a kind of unfit in MANIT would be a complete injustice.
During his stint there we saw many changes (good ones!) in MACT. Few of them were-
1. Foremost was improvement in academics. It wasn't too huge for batch like ours which had became sort of complacent in first two years, but it was visible in our junior batches.
However, the quality of professors already present posed some limitations.
Students were now less terrorized by the high handedness of some of the profs (... and it seemed that some of these profs were uncomfortable after losing the powers which can be 'misused')
2. Accountability had certainly improved, with the system becoming more transparent, and bureaucracy reduced.
3. Completion of many projects that were moving at snail's pace or were long overdue during his tenure - chiefly CC ... even SAC and canteen!
Sadly, it seemed that some power hungry profs couldn't digest these all!
As for Prof Chande, he teaches in one of the IIMs now ... This itself speaks a lot about him !
~ Nikesh (2001 -2005 batch)
Post a Comment